London, 16 Apr 2003.
For immediate release.

Contact the ABD

Previous
Press Release
Next

Minister's Statement "Inaccurate and Mischievous"
Road Safety Minister David Jamieson has written in the magazine of the Institute of Advanced Motorists that
"The figures that are often quoted of speed contributing to no more than four per cent to seven per cent of accidents are inaccurate and mischievous."

ABD Road Safety Spokesman Mark McArthur-Christie commented:

"The minister's words are a classic case of the pot calling the kettle black. We have some serious doubts about the way the government has used statistics to justify the use of cameras."
Despite a wealth of data to the contrary, the government continues to repeat the claim "one third of accidents are caused by speed".

Their claim is based upon the Transport Research Laboratory's report number 323 in which police officers attending accidents recorded the factors behind the accident.

There was more than one factor in most accidents. Factors were classed as definite, probable or possible. Excessive speed amounted to 7.3% of the total factors recorded, it was a definite factor in only about 4% of accidents, but was a possible factor — although not necessarily the primary factor (cause) — in up to 15%.

Although excessive speed was only 7.3% of the factors, a number of other factors have since been cited as "speed related":-

Since more than one factor was recorded in most accidents, attempts by the government to use factors such as 'slippery road' to boost the proportion attributed to speed amount to double counting, since it is quite likely that, where these factors are recorded, excessive speed will have been noted as another factor already. You can't count the same accident twice as being due to speed!

ABD Chairman Brian Gregory said

"How the minister can claim that statistical evidence gathered by police officers attending accidents is 'inaccurate and mischievous' is surprising. Perhaps this is why the government are replacing police traffic officers with speed cameras — they cost less to run, make more money, and don't answer back. But they also completely fail to catch the drivers who are a danger on our roads."

 

 
Notes for Editors